Market Stats so Scary they were Released on Friday the 13th

The local Vancouver Clark County Real Estate market report, as generated by RMLS, came out Friday the 13th of all days,and whether you are a Triskaidekaphobiac or not, these were some scary numbers.

While Months of Inventory (of houses for sale) was down January to February, it was up year-over-year/February. There’s enough real estate data points, ratios and percentages to give anybody wiggle room to spin this report. Really, with enough paint, you can paint this report any color you’d like… as for me, my favorite color has always been transparent.  I know lots of folks can simply throw out the numbers. And while that is the easiest way to get information into the public’s eye, I prefer to dig a little deeper and look at those same numbers from multiple, transparent, perspectives.

Most importantly, where will the Vancouver Clark County real estate market go from here? As a reminder, Months of Inventory (MOI) is defined by dividing the Active Listings at the end of that month by the Number of Closed Sales during that month [Active/Closed]. In my humble opinion, MOI is a key indicator of where we are at and where we are going.  Says something about supply and demand.  I guess that’s important economic mumbo-jumbo.

With MOI in the Vancouver Clark County real estate market standing at 18.6 months in February, it was a 11.4% decrease in MOI from January (yay!), sounds good right?  Sure, but February historically has a decrease in MOI from January.  Problem being that when you consider the average MOI decrease over the past two years from January to February was more than 17%, it doesn’t smell as pretty. Basically, while we decreased MOI January to February, we did it at a slower than historical rate.  In technical jargon, that’s called a bummer.  Still with me?

OK. So we get that the reduction in MOI was slower January to February this year than in the past, that’s just one number.  While I agree, lets continue digging.  Unless you’ve been living under a rock (whereby you’d have little concern about the time it takes to sell a house) you know that MOI has been increasing year over year for the past three years.  More importantly to me is the rate of increase.  For the last four months of 2008, the average year-over-year increase in MOI was 21.2% – that by itself is a BIG number.  Problem is that in January, that number grew to 23.5% and in February, it was 27.4% – Yikes!  While the Law of Large Numbers says it can’t go on this way forever, the year-over-year MOI number is still expanding. Not a good thing.

Back to my question… where do we need to go from here?  Please understand, I bought my crystal ball off of eBay, so I’m not saying its perfect.  But here’s what I’d look for in the March report.  I’d like to see the MOI for Vancouver Clark County in the 14.6-14.9 range (or less, of course!).  One, that would gain some positive traction for decreasing the historical February to March MOI reductions; and two, that would reverse the trend of expanding year-over-year percentage increases back below the number from the past three months. Now really, while I’d like to see that number at about 7.5, I’d simply take movement in the right direction for  now.

I know, them there’s a lot of numbers. And while I may come across as the boogie-man on a scary Friday, I really do think we are searching for a bottom. I talked before about not buying the rah-rah hype.  But, I believe we are finally closer to the bottom than we are the top. The last three offers I’ve written for clients all had multiple offers on the house. Pricing numbers are well on their way to returning to the historical trendline. We’ll likely continue to have an influx of short-sale and repo/REO inventory that will keep a lid on an explosive bounce from the bottom, but if trading stocks for six years in a previous life taught me anything, I know that no one rings a bell when it’s time to buy.

So while it may be scary out there, it’s always darkest before the dawn.